Proposal Details

Proposal #796

Rejected

Proposal title

Nullify proposal 75

Submit time

Deposit end time

Voting start time

Voting end time

Tally result

53.66%

Proposal #796 description

The cosmos hub has an elegant method for dealing with spam, known as veto. It deals with genuine spam proposals very well. But what does it mean under the hood? Well, what it means under the hood is that you vote for no and you vote for veto at the same time, you’re making two votes. If the tally for veto reaches 33%, the deposit on the proposal is burned and the proposal automatically fails.

Since there is absolutely no way to mandate a definition of spam and everybody is going to interpret that differently and it makes no sense whatsoever to argue about that, I propose that we nullify proposal 75, AND free the authors of governance proposals from writing tedious vote options because those are defined very well in the software. Luckily, our community is more than intelligent enough to interpret on their own, what the vote options do, and the documentation of the vote options is highly effective.

Finally, I believe that it makes sense to require only explaining the yes option, as doing otherwise can land a punter in hot water.

Therefore, to make governance simpler in all ways, and increase participation in governance, and remove the crazy burn two sticks of incense and say 10 hail Marys before approaching Cosmos hub governance to save thyself from Gaia’s proceduralist faction, we should do the logical thing, and require only that YES, be defined. All other vote options are defined by the underlying software and its documentation.

vote YES to nullify proposal 75, require that YES be defined, and use all other vote options as described by the cosmos-sdk.

Proposal #796 overview

Total votes

66,149

Voters

65,110

Total deposit

250 ATOM

Proposal #796 votes

#	Validator	Options
1	ECO Stake 🌱	No
2	B-Harvest	Abstain
3	Allnodes	Abstain
4	Everstake	No
5	HashKey Cloud	Abstain
6	Compass	No
7	a41	Abstain
8	HyperblocksPro	Abstain
9	DSRV	Yes
10	Stir	Abstain
11	LOA Labs	Abstain
12	P2P.ORG - P2P Validator	No
13	0base.vc	Abstain
14	blockscape	Abstain
15	🙏 uGaenn ⛅	No
16	Chorus One	No
17	HighStakes.ch \| Stake for Airdrop	No
18	NodeStake	Yes
19	IcyCRO 🧊	No
20	ShapeShift DAO	Abstain
21	Provalidator	Abstain
22	S16 Research Ventures	Abstain
23	BlockHunters 🎯	Yes
24	Blockdaemon	Abstain
25	Moonlet	Abstain
26	Blocks United \| blocksunited.com	No
27	Chill Validation	Yes
28	debo[REDELEGATE FROM US]	No
29	GAME	No
30	Cosmos Spaces	Yes
31	StakeLab.zone	No
32	01node	Abstain
33	Enigma	Abstain
34	Lavender.Five Nodes 🐝	No
35	Bro_n_Bro	Abstain
36	CrowdControl	No
37	Simply Staking	No
38	Informal Systems	No
39	CEX.IO Validator	Abstain
40	Cosmostation	Abstain
41	Coinage x DAIC	Abstain
42	StakeSeeker by BTCS	Abstain
43	Cosmic Validator \| 100% Uptime & Auto-compound	Abstain
44	SG-1	Abstain
45	PUPMØS	Yes
46	ChainLayer	Yes
47	Silk Nodes	Abstain
48	Citizen Web3	Yes
49	Kintsugi Nodes	No
50	commercio.network	Abstain
51	Imperator.co	Abstain
52	IRISNET	Abstain
53	NosNode⚛️	Yes
54	GATA HUB	No
55	🌐 KysenPool Sky ☁️	Abstain
56	Easy 2 Stake	No
57	Virtual Hive	Yes
58	Active Nodes	Abstain
59	Vitwit (Previously Witval)	No
60	Stakewolle.com \|100% Insurance	Yes
61	BlockPI	Abstain
62	Crypto Lion	Abstain
63	FreshSTAKING	No
64	UNSTAKE/RE-DELEGATE	No
65	Meria	No
66	Stakely.io	Abstain
67	Golden Ratio Staking	Abstain
68	Stakecito	Abstain
69	Keplr	No
70	Blockpower	Abstain
71	coinhall.org 📈🔄	Yes
72	Zero Knowledge Validator (ZKV)	Abstain
73	StakeWithUs	Abstain
74	Node Guardians	Abstain
75	ChainUp & NewHuo	Yes
76	HLT	Yes
77	Stakin	Yes
78	jabbey	Yes
79	vido.info	Abstain
80	Kiln	Yes
81	WhisperNode 🤐	Yes
82	✅ CryptoCrew Validators 🏆 Winner #GameOfChains	Yes
83	[SHUTTING DOWN] AUDIT.one	Abstain
84	Binary Holdings	Yes
85	Frens (🤝,🤝)	Yes
86	Oni ⛩️ \| Stake for BoostDrop™ 🚀	Yes
87	BitValidator	Yes
88	🐹 Quokka Stake	Yes
89	stake.systems \| autocompound	Yes
90	Fanfury \| fury.fan \| Stake to Win	Yes
91	Ubik Capital	No
92	Nocturnal Labs	Yes
93	dForce	Abstain
94	CROSSTECH	Yes
95	TTT 🇻🇳	Yes
96	Multiplex	Yes
97	Architect Nodes	Yes
98	in3s.com	Yes
99	windpowerstake	No
100	w3coins	Yes

View:

Cosmos Hub

Proposal Details

Proposal #796

Proposal #796 description

Proposal #796 overview

Proposal #796 votes