Proposal Details

Proposal #95

Rejected

Proposal title

Retroactive Payment for Public Goods (Evmos Development for March 2022)

Submit time

Deposit end time

Voting start time

Voting end time

Tally result

51.06%

Proposal #95 description

Retroactive Payment for Public Goods (Evmos Development for March 2022)

Discussion: https://commonwealth.im/evmos/discussion/8571-retroactive-payment-for-public-goods-evmos-development-for-march-2022

Since proposal 88 has been rejected, the volunteers for Tharsis and Evmos will have the opportunity to ask the Evmos chain for clarification of the status of their efforts.

Exposition

The for-profit developers of Tharsis were paid by salary for their development work. Then Tharsis extracted tens of millions of dollars from the apparent value of the Evmos chain to pay themselves again.

The Laurel Project which volunteered for Tharsis for developing a good portion of the Evmos chain tech and some Ethermint coding will also ask the Evmos Community if their efforts will be accepted in perpetuity as volunteering or if they will be paid as retroactive public goods funding.

The Public Goods Created

Proofs

    1. The proof that the output of the effort exists as a public good: the videos exist and are public on YouTube, and the code exists and is public.
    1. The proof that it is about the Evmos chain/tech: the code is used by Ethermint/Evmos.
    1. The proof that the effort is of the quality and quantity claimed: Federico Kunze signed the confirmations for the effort, as a comment on https://github.com/loredanacirstea/CV/issues/2. The exact text was:

I confirm and acknowledge the stated output. Thanks @loredanacirstea! πŸ’― Federico Kunze KΓΌllmer - CEO Tharsis Labs / Co-Founder Evmos Fri, Mar 25, 2022, by @fedekunze

but he recently deleted that comment (he deleted all his public confirmations of my volunteering).

  • 4. The proof that this chain accepts claims for retroactive public goods is proposal 88.

Retroactive Payment

  • 359.5h * 255 EUR/h = 91,672.5 EUR
  • current price: 0.265110 EUR/ $EVMOS

Total: 345,790 $EVMOS

The Meaning of the Decision

    1. If this proposal passes: the Evmos chain pays retroactively for this public good.
    1. If this proposal does not pass: the Evmos chain recognizes in perpetuity this public good as a volunteering effort of The Laurel Project in the interest of the Evmos Community. (or is bound to produce counter-proofs to the ones above). The presented effort was made with the intent of being offered to the Evmos Community as a volunteer effort. The legitimate repayment for volunteer effort is the recognition of said effort.
    1. No with veto: the chain benefits from and uses this free, unpaid effort, but it has decided to punish the author of this effort, for requesting formal recognition of the volunteered effort.

Receiver Address

evmos1k9pw7ht4kp7td5450sdrkj2tmly3ug59ddhadn

Author

Loredana Cirstea, volunteer for The Laurel Project.

Proposal #95 overview

Total votes
7,906
Voters
7,587
Total deposit
192 EVMOS

Proposal #95 votes

#

Validator

Account Address

Options
1Cosmos SpacesNo With Veto
2TessellatedNo With Veto
3ValidaviaNo
4#decentralizehk - DHK daoNo
5StakeLab.zoneNo
60base.vcNo With Veto
7HashKey CloudNo
8Chorus OneNo
9Cypher CoreNo With Veto
10Jerry's PoolNo
11CosmostationNo
12NotionalNo With Veto
13Please RedelegateAbstain
14Bro_n_BroNo
15Citizen Web3No
16stake.systemsAbstain
17AlphabetYes (0%), Abstain (0%)
18Smart Stake πŸ“ˆπŸ“ŠNo
19blockscapeNo With Veto
20🐸 SpacePepe Labs πŸ”¬βœ…πŸŽYes
21Please REDELEGATENo
22ChainToolsNo
23Please Redelegate. Shutting downNo With Veto
24MCB | mcbnodeNo
25βœ… CryptoCrew - 100% MEV revenue to Evmos stakers! #IBCgang #REstakeNo
26Crypto Lion 🦁Abstain
27MultiplexNo
28wb3addctdAbstain
29DO-NOT-DELEGATENo
30Shutdown-REDELEGATENo
31BlockwavelabsNo With Veto
32Blockwave LabsNo With Veto
33sleepykittenNo
34[Beehive]No
35DefierEvmosAbstain
36REDELEGATE | CLOSING 06/06/23No
37<decommissioned>No With Veto
38PolychainNo With Veto
39Stake Frites πŸ₯© 🍟No
40Redelegate-to-new-Stakecito-NodeNo With Veto
41Hanchon.liveNo With Veto
42Swiss StakingNo With Veto
43ProvalidatorAbstain
44ECO Stake 🌱No
45DeFi100-iCosmosDAO πŸ’―βš›οΈNo
46Informal SystemsNo
47Frens (🀝,🀝)No
48Node is being decommissionedNo
49ZKValidatorNo
50InteropAbstain
5101nodeAbstain
52NodeStakeNo
53Imperator.coNo
54Vault Staking | Slash ProtectedNo
55Out of active set, please redelegate your tokensNo
56Let's Node | Expandingspace.ioNo
57MZONDERNo With Veto
58CrosnestNo With Veto
59Stakely.ioNo With Veto
60NacionCrypto - ParcerosNo
61Citadel.oneAbstain
62DisperzeNo
63BitNordicNo With Veto
64Chill ValidationNo
65pro-nodes75No
66AutoStake πŸ›‘οΈ Slash ProtectedAbstain
67DragonStake 🐲No
68Klub Staking - SHUTTING DOWN - Redelegate to MeriaNo
69[Sunsetting, please redelegate] ForboleAbstain
70Deprecated ValidatorNo
71Tedcrypto.io 🧸 | TedLottoNo With Veto
72HoodRunNo
73P2P ValidatorNo With Veto
74Nodes.GuruAbstain
75AUDIT.oneNo
76QubelabsNo With Veto
77a41No
78Gelotto πŸ›‘ Slash ProtectedNo
792xStake.comAbstain
80TC NetworkNo With Veto
81RHINO | 10% to WildlifeNo
82heisenbugNo
83CLOSING 2024.03.31 REDELEGATENo
84Lavender.Five Nodes 🐝No With Veto
85Let's Node!No
86SecorDNo
87AgoraNodesNo With Veto
88jabbeyNo
89GalaxyStaking.space πŸŒ‘No With Veto
90OrbitalApes.comNo With Veto
91MandragoraNo With Veto
92kallenNo
93MMSAbstain
94Please Redelegate, Closing Down.No With Veto
95Regenerator | Green Validator 🌱No With Veto
96windpowerstakeNo With Veto
97Stakin | DiscontinuedAbstain
98silentNo With Veto
99KingSuperAbstain
100ericetNo

View: