Proposal Details

Proposal #93

Rejected

Proposal title

Governance Consensus: The Governance Language is English

Submit time

Deposit end time

Voting start time

Voting end time

Tally result

44.88%

Proposal #93 description

The Natural Language for the Governance of the Evmos Chain is English

Discussion: https://commonwealth.im/evmos/discussion/8551-governance-consensus-the-governance-language-is-english

Purpose

Clarify the parameters for the natural language used in Evmos Governance.

Exposition

To achieve authority of Governance, the chain needs to establish the most accessible ground for debate and voting. The language for the process of Governance is one of the main parameters and we consider that the best language for Evmos Governance is the English language.

Since the meaning of the sentence and therefore paragraph can be changed by choice of word meaning, by the punctuation signs, and by the resultant syntax tree, a consensus has to be reached on the unique arbiter for each, including the syntax tree of a proposal (in whole or in part).

Rules

  1. The accepted English dictionary for words and concepts and their semantic linking shall be the latest version of The Princeton Wordnet. http://www.lexvo.org/uwn/ with language option: English (eng).

    The alternatives, in order (in their order of use when a source is unavailable):

  2. Any governance text may contain words with subscript that indicates the order of sense of the word as it appears in WordNet. For example:

The chair3 position is the most important.

refers to the third meaning of the word 'chair' from http://www.lexvo.org/uwn/entity/eng/chair : (noun) the officer who presides at the meetings of an organization; 'address your remarks to the chairperson' chairman, chairwoman, chairperson, president, chair

  1. If concepts are not found in the source designated by point (1): Wikipedia may be used. https://en.wikipedia.org/

  2. The syntax tree source shall be http://lindat.mff.cuni.cz/services/udpipe/ with its English option.

    The alternatives, in order:

Meaning of the Decision

  • if this proposal passes: the governance process gains additional legitimacy by recognizing prior consensus contained in the gov language itself

  • if this proposal does not pass: the token holders forfeit the right to reject a proposal (on-chain or off-chain) on account of not being made using proper, verifiable English

Additional Benefits of Adopting

The subsequent proposals (on and off-chain) may be legitimately challenged on:

  • the natural language used
  • clarifying the meaning of a specific word
  • sources of truth (such as a unique dictionary)
  • syntax or semantic ambiguities

Only the chains that will pass proposals compatible with this one will have the legitimacy to enter common governance platforms for the InterChain. By this prop, we offered Evmos the opportunity to be the early leader in that respect.

Author

Christian Tzurcanu, volunteer for The Laurel Project. Efforts performed for The InterChain Pact office.

Proposal #93 overview

Total votes
7,101
Voters
6,908
Total deposit
192 EVMOS

Proposal #93 votes

#

Validator

Account Address

Options
1Coinage x DAICAbstain
2Informal SystemsNo
3ECO Stake 🌱Abstain
4Citizen Web3No
5CrosnestNo
6Chorus OneNo
7ValidatusAbstain
8TC NetworkAbstain
90base.vcNo
10Smart Stake πŸ“ˆπŸ“ŠNo
11πŸ™ uGaenn β›…No
1201nodeAbstain
13Please Redelegate. Shutting downAbstain
14Hanchon.liveNo
15Shutting Down | Please RedelegateAbstain
16StakeLab.zoneNo
17Lex_PrimeNo
18AG_Node_EvmosAbstain
19CLOSING 2024.03.31 REDELEGATENo
20GATA HUBAbstain
21jabbeyNo
22Tedcrypto.io 🧸 | TedLottoNo
23baileyNo
24Redelegate-to-new-Stakecito-NodeAbstain
25βœ… CryptoCrew - 100% MEV revenue to Evmos stakers! #IBCgang #REstakeNo
26KalpaTechNo
27Cosmos SpacesNo With Veto
28MandragoraAbstain
29Please RedelegateAbstain
30Cypher CoreAbstain
31DragonStake 🐲Abstain
32Nodes.GuruAbstain
33ericetAbstain
34NodeStakeNo
35STAKE MARSAbstain
36Lavender.Five Nodes 🐝Yes
37Stakely.ioNo
38TR-3B ASTRAAbstain
39Please REDELEGATEAbstain
40OrbitalApes.comNo
41Gelotto πŸ›‘ Slash ProtectedNo
42Node is being decommissionedNo
43BwareLabsAbstain
44Golden Ratio StakingNo With Veto
45Legion NodesNo
46ZKValidatorAbstain
47HoodRunAbstain
48DeFi100-iCosmosDAO πŸ’―βš›οΈAbstain
49silentNo
50Klub Staking - SHUTTING DOWN - Redelegate to MeriaYes
51Jerry's PoolYes
522xStake.comAbstain
53Shutdown-REDELEGATEAbstain
54[Beehive]Abstain
55Vault Staking | Slash ProtectedAbstain
56<decommissioned>No
57PolychainNo
58NotionalAbstain
59AlphabetYes
60Stake Frites πŸ₯© 🍟No
61AlphaNodesπŸ›ΈAbstain
62POSTHUMAN ꝏ DVSNo
63BlockHunters 🎯No With Veto
64wb3addctdAbstain
65Architect NodesNo With Veto
66carbonZERO🌲No
67WhisperNode🀐No
68Bro_n_BroAbstain
69blockscapeAbstain
70TessellatedNo
71Deprecated ValidatorYes
72SHUTTING DOWN PLEASE REDELEGATEAbstain
73Regenerator | Green Validator 🌱No
74Please Redelegate, Closing Down.No
75ProvalidatorAbstain
76CosmoshieldNo With Veto
77CosmosPug πŸ’Abstain
78Chill ValidationNo
79MZONDERNo
80Frens (🀝,🀝)Abstain
81Stakin | DiscontinuedNo
82Swiss StakingNo
83MCB | mcbnodeYes
84pro-nodes75No
85ValidaviaAbstain
86AutoStake πŸ›‘οΈ Slash ProtectedYes
87sleepykittenYes
88🐸 SpacePepe Labs πŸ”¬βœ…πŸŽYes
89KingSuperAbstain
90kallenAbstain
91CosmostationAbstain
92DO-NOT-DELEGATEAbstain
93DisperzeAbstain
94Imperator.coNo
95Let's Node!No
96SecorDNo
97rxpwnz β˜„οΈ | Genesis ValidatorAbstain
98Let's Node | Expandingspace.ioYes
99QubelabsNo
100alkadetaNo With Veto

View: